Monday, January 28, 2013

Coleridge's Take on Ham and Pol

Samuel Taylor Coleridge, who wrote "Rime of the Ancient Mariner," was a well-known critic of Hamlet.  Two of his more popular insights are:

-->On Hamlet. - "Hamlet's character is the prevalence of the abstracting and generalizing habit over the practical. He does not want courage, skill, will, or opportunity; but every incident sets him thinking; and it is curious, and at the same time strictly natural, that Hamlet, who all the play seems reason itself, should be impelled, at last, by mere accident, to effect his object. I have a smack of Hamlet myself, if I may say so." - June 15, 1827.

On Polonius. - "A Maxim is a conclusion upon observation of matters of fact, and is merely retrospective; an idea, or, if you like, a Principle, carries knowledge within itself, and is prospective. Polonius is a man of maxims. While he is descanting on matters of past experience, as in that excellent speech to Laertes before he sets out on his travels, he is admirable; but when he comes to advise or project, he is a mere dotard. You see Hamlet, as the man of ideas, despises him. A man of maxims only is like a Cyclops with one eye, and that eye placed in the back of his head." - June 15, 1827.

Thought you might find these helpful in your discussion with Johnston...

Let me know if you have any questions.